“Head coach Dusty May has stated that it’s too early to assess the freshmen, and none have stood out significantly in early practices as he claims that…

“Head coach Dusty May has stated that it’s too early to assess the freshmen, and none have stood out significantly in early practices as he claims that…

 

Too Early to Tell: Dusty May Plays It Cautious with Freshmen Evaluations Amid Florida Basketball’s Quiet Rebuild

 

In his first few weeks as head coach of the Florida Gators, Dusty May has wasted no time installing his culture, emphasizing discipline, communication, and basketball IQ. But if fans or analysts were hoping for an early freshman phenom to emerge from Gainesville’s revamped roster, May is urging everyone to slow down. In a recent media availability, May openly acknowledged that it’s “too early to assess the freshmen,” noting that “none have stood out significantly in early practices” and stressing that development — not hype — remains his priority.

 

> “We’re still figuring out who’s adjusting to the pace, who’s consistent with their habits, and who understands the expectations day in and day out,” May said. “This is a marathon, not a sprint.”

 

 

 

That quote encapsulates the cautious optimism surrounding a Florida program in the early stages of a transition. While the Gators landed several promising freshmen in the 2024 recruiting cycle — and have begun to draw national attention under May’s leadership — the coaching staff is making a concerted effort to temper expectations. Here’s a deeper look at why no one’s been crowned the next great Gator just yet, and what May’s comments might mean for the future of the program.

 

 

—

 

A Deliberate Culture Reset

 

Dusty May’s arrival in Gainesville was seen as a stabilizing move after several years of inconsistency under previous head coaches. Known for his success in building Florida Atlantic into a national contender — including a Final Four run — May brings a system-oriented philosophy that prioritizes structure over star power.

 

That mindset is especially evident in how he’s handling the incoming freshmen.

 

> “There’s a big difference between playing high school ball and competing in the SEC,” he said. “We want to make sure our guys are mentally and physically prepared before throwing them into the fire.”

 

 

 

Sources within the program describe early practices as “methodical” and “defensive-minded,” with a focus on decision-making, defensive communication, and off-ball movement. It’s a system that can take time for young players to absorb, and the coaching staff is in no rush to accelerate anyone’s timeline.

 

 

—

 

The Freshman Class: High Potential, Long Road

 

Florida’s 2024 freshman class isn’t short on talent, even if no one has broken through just yet. Headlined by combo guard Jalen Hill, 6’9” forward Ryan Tinsley, and athletic wing Kamar Jenkins, the group brings a mix of athleticism, versatility, and upside.

 

Jalen Hill, a four-star recruit from Georgia, was expected by many to challenge for early minutes as a ball-handler and secondary scorer. But according to team sources, Hill has been adjusting to the physicality of college defenses and the speed of May’s offensive reads.

 

> “Jalen’s got a great feel, but there’s an adjustment period,” one assistant said. “He’s learning to make decisions quicker and become more vocal as a floor general.”

 

 

 

Ryan Tinsley, the highest-rated frontcourt prospect in the class, has drawn praise for his rebounding instincts and mobility, but he’s still behind in terms of defensive positioning and strength.

 

Kamar Jenkins, the high-flying wing from New Orleans, has shown flashes of scoring ability in scrimmages but has struggled with consistency and shot selection — two traits that Dusty May is known to monitor closely.

 

Still, it’s early. May and his staff are focusing on fundamentals, spacing, and effort, not flashy highlights.

 

> “We evaluate based on daily habits, not one good practice or dunk in transition,” May emphasized.

 

 

 

 

—

 

Veteran-Led Locker Room Leaves Little Room for Instant Stardom

 

Another reason why no freshman has taken center stage? The veterans.

 

Florida returns several experienced players who have already earned the trust of the coaching staff. Grad transfers like Zyon Pullin and returning contributors like Alex Condon and Will Richard are setting the tone in practice, both vocally and through execution.

 

> “The older guys are doing a great job holding everyone accountable,” said assistant coach Kyle Church. “That allows the freshmen to learn without being rushed into situations they’re not ready for.”

 

 

 

The presence of veterans also provides a developmental buffer. Rather than being thrust into 25-minute roles right away, freshmen can grow at their own pace — a luxury not every program enjoys.

 

This approach mirrors May’s player development philosophy from his FAU days, where most players didn’t reach peak impact until their second or third year.

 

 

—

 

Behind the Scenes: What Staff Are Really Looking For

 

While fans may be searching for a breakout name, the coaching staff is measuring freshmen in more nuanced ways. Internal metrics track things like defensive rotations, communication in ball screens, offensive spacing discipline, and decision-making under duress — qualities that may not show up in stat sheets but are crucial for earning minutes in May’s system.

 

> “It’s not about who scores the most in practice,” strength and conditioning coach Bryan Green said. “It’s about who wins drills, who competes every possession, who dives on the floor.”

 

 

 

In that sense, May’s public statements are also designed to protect his players from premature expectations. Rather than letting social media buzz distort the process, he’s choosing to create a closed, focused environment where players are evaluated on internal standards.

 

 

—

 

Development Over Exposure: A Calculated Media Strategy

 

The decision not to name a standout freshman isn’t just about honesty — it’s strategic. In an era where recruiting rankings and highlight clips often overshadow actual development, Dusty May is working hard to manage the narrative.

 

By emphasizing patience and downplaying early hype, May protects his young players from the pressure cooker of expectations. He also sends a message to future recruits and their families: if you come to Florida, you’ll be developed, not exploited.

 

It’s a subtle but powerful branding move that aligns with the identity May wants to build — one rooted in trust, discipline, and long-term growth.

 

 

—

 

What History Tells Us: May’s Freshmen Rarely Peak Early

 

If past seasons are any indicator, Dusty May has never been one to fast-track freshmen. At Florida Atlantic, players like Johnell Davis and Alijah Martin saw gradual minutes as freshmen before emerging as stars later in their careers.

 

The same model is now being applied at Florida. Don’t be surprised if none of the 2024 freshmen average more than 10–12 minutes early in the season — especially with a tough non-conference schedule that includes games against top-25 opponents.

 

> “We want our young guys to be prepared to contribute in January and February — not necessarily November,” May said.

 

 

 

That’s when SEC play heats up, and the margin for error disappears. If the freshmen can learn their roles, earn the trust of the staff, and buy into the system, their impact could be enormous down the stretch.

 

 

—

 

Patience Pays Off: What to Expect by Midseason

 

So what should fans realistically expect from the freshman class this year?

 

In the short term: flashes. You might see Jalen Hill hit a clutch three in a close game. Or Ryan Tinsley snag a key offensive rebound and kick out for a corner three. Or Kamar Jenkins get hot off the bench and swing a momentum run.

 

But it won’t be about stats. It’ll be about impact within the system — how they complement veterans, execute schemes, and play winning basketball.

 

By midseason, the picture will be clearer. One or two freshmen may crack the rotation full-time. Others may spend the year learning and preparing for a bigger role in 2025–26. And that’s perfectly fine with May.

 

> “We’re not here to showcase freshmen,” he said. “We’re here to build a team that can win games in March.”

 

 

 

 

—

 

The Bottom Line: Trust the Process

 

Dusty May’s message is clear: don’t confuse early silence with lack of talent. The freshmen are still learning, adjusting, and competing. Their time will come — but only when they’ve earned it.

 

In an era where five-star prospects often expect instant stardom, Florida is offering something more sustainable: a developmental environment where players are molded, not marketed.

 

That might not produce headlines in July. But come March? That’s when this approach could pay off in a big way.

 

For now, May and his staff will continue to coach, correct, and cultivate. And if the early practices are any indi

cation, the Florida freshmen are right where they need to be — working, learning, and preparing to surprise everyone down the line.